face
Posted : 8/12/2009 12:40:47 PM
Welcome to the World of Horse Shows.
Following is a RANT I did in my BLOG on a website I run, www.sc-horse.com. While I state I prefer timed events, I have been told that "in-experienced" riders should not go to horse shows". Which leads me to wonder, how do you get experience? In my case, my horse does great on her home turf, but not when I take her somewhere else. The only way she will get better is if I keep taking her!
Anyway, here is the RANT!
My favorite horse events are the timed events such as barrel racing and pole bending. Why? Because they are not subject to horse politics and opinions of individuals who tend to favor the people they know. With timed events, it is what it is.
My first experience with a horse show was at The Egyptian Event at the Kentucky Horse Park. In one of the events a VERY young boy was halter showing. He was a crowd favorite and he won. However, the horse he had could have done it#%92s thing without the young boy. Come to find out, he won the previous year. In the end, the question must be raised, did the best horse and person combination win. The general concenus was, “NO!”
On the final night of the show it was all about the stallions. The final night was broadcast live on Saudi Arabian TV. There was a Saudi Arabian prince who had his horses being shown, and if his horses were entered, they won. The very final event was between 3 stallions. Once from Texas and two that the Saudi prince owned. I am no expert when it comes to such things and from what I saw it was between the Texas horse and
ONE of the prince#%92s horse. As you notice I emphasis
ONE of the prince#%92s horses. His second horse was totally of control and performed horribly. However, the prince#%92s horses came in 1st and 2nd with the Texas horse coming in 3rd. It was all about politics and giving the Saudia Aranian TV audience what they wanted. SO VERY SAD!
All of this of course is very apparent at the local South Carolina shows as well. Local judges tend to favor the local kids that they know. Visiting kids are at a huge disadvantage. It can be quite apparent when the announcers make a big deal, as the kids are competing in the arena, about how great the local kids are looking and say nothing when the the visitors are competing. These arenas need to remember the visitors are spending money and time hauling their horses to their shows and paying for the classes as well as paying for their concessions. If they are not treated fairly, guess what, they ain#%92t coming back, your reputation for such tactics will spread and your revenue will drop.
My brother-in-law recently attended a Hunter/Jumper show where his daughter was competing. He actually stood next to judges who would go gaw gaw over the local kids and when the visiting kids were competing, they would not even watch and spent the time having conversations on topics not even related to horses.
UNACCECTABLE In the end, this does no good for the kids. The kids that win that shouldn#%92t have started to get the attitude that they are better than they are and this will slow their improvement. The kids that deserve to win get fed up and QUIT. Not all facilities host competitions so not everyone has the advantage of being on the home turf.
If you experience and witness bad judging behavior you need to inform the people running that show and explain if this is the type of show they run, then you will not be back and you will share your view with others. I have seen new show circuits start in South Carolina because of the unfair judging that is going on.
Once concept might be to doing judging like a high school band competition. Judges feel out juding forms which have different captions for what they are judging. They may comments on the forms. They could make audio tapes where they comment on the individuals performance as it takes place. With a band, the goal is to get feedback on how you are doing. You have your band directors opinion, but this gives another perspective. It is a tool for improvement. I believe people go to horse shows for the fun of competition and to learn. What better way to learn than to hear some comments from the judges. A summary of all scores should also be posted for review by all.
This is just my 2 cents and my solution would not solve the issue but I think it would help. There is politics in band competions as well.