wundahoss
Posted : 4/12/2010 12:09:21 AM
Yep, another one for shoeless here! I'm a hoof care practitioner & with my experience, have come to firmly believe that conventional metal shoes are rarely the best option. I specialise in founder, 'navicular' & other problems & apart from rare exceptions, I believe shoes are unhelpful & generally more damaging when applied to an unhealthy hoof. But I don't think shoes are *necessarily* bad when applied to a healthy, strong foot(assuming the job, management, etc is done well).
Why did I say 'shoeless' not 'barefoot'?? Because unfortunately, due to the environment domestic horses tend to be kept on & the management/exercise they get, it is difficult or impossible for many horses to develop 'rock crunching' go - anywhere feet. It is not helpful, or much good for the horse to just make them go bare if they're uncomfortable(landing toe first, for eg). Therefore they do indeed often need protection & support. Conventional shoes don't provide this, at least without the addition of pads & such, and with the other 'side effects' of shoes I see hoof boots as a vastly better option generally, than metal rims.
I think educating ourselves as best we can, rather than blindly trusting the 'experts' is extremely important, on whatever matters are important to us - be that shoeing or 'barefooting' our horses or whatever other subjects. There are so many opinions, conflicting information, many factors(such as the above) that effect what the best answers may be, that you need to do your homework, weigh up the pros & cons of each approach, before you can make the best informed decision. On that note, regarding hoofcare, hoofrehab.com barehoofcare.com & barefoothorse.com are among some of the good sites you can start your education with.
OP, regarding your 45-60 day trim cycle, of course it depends on the horse & work she does, etc, but that's actually a rather long period. If she's recently been shod, I'd expect her feet to now start growing quicker. Most shod horses should be optimally trimmed around 6 weekly. Some that hardly grow can stretch it a bit further. But the general trim cycle for bare feet seem to be optimally between 3-6 weeks on average.
Many people are unsure about the difference between - and whether to use - a farrier or 'hoof care practitioner' or whatever title we 'shoeless' mob give ourselves
IMO, while around these parts, it seems that farriers tend to be rather lacking in much more knowledge than rasping feet flat to apply shoes.... A *good* farrier should be just as knowledgeable as a *good* hcp. They do often trim in different ways(such as low heels, 'mustang rolls'...), that often seems to come down to whether farriers have studied the new(ish) research & info at hand, whether they understand the ways hooves function & why things like 'navicular' & the likes come about. HCPs have generally studied this extensively, along with other factors such as diet & management, and can also advise owners on these matters. But be aware, just as there are bad or ignorant or incompetent farriers around, there are those same type in the hcp business too. So there's another reason to get yourself educated enough that you can tell the difference & find yourself a worthwhile 'expert' to help you.