wundahoss
Posted : 3/23/2010 11:55:31 PM
Hi Ryle,
I note in your sig. that you're a vet. tech. Is that a vet, or vet nurse, vet researcher ...? Sorry, I'm in Aus & not sure what it means. I also took note of your second post, which is something that came to mind reading this - may depend where you're talking about as to qualifications, etc. I also didn't emphasise finding a *good* bodyworker, not just any, which I'm usually pedantic about, because I realise there are good & bad in whatever area, be it vets, bodyworkers, farriers, hcps... As for my comment about vets learning the basics to get general ideas, I agree that that is too blase sounding, not quite what I meant, but gives the gist of it. Of course they are trained in a range of 'specifics' too, but what I meant is that they're not generally anything like specialists in all or relevant areas.
I basically agree with most of what you say, but my point was, while vets will have a lot more education & training, it's general - eg. they must learn about all parts of many different species. Therefore, while they *may* be good at diagnosing whatever, unless they specialise or take special interest in certain areas, they may know far less than a physio(assuming decent education & experience, not just 5 hr course) about body probs, far less than a (well educated)hcp or farrier about feet, for eg.
Chiro's and body workers again do not have the in-depth training and education so do not even know what the majority of the possible causes for a certain set of symptoms is. (You can't know what the problem is if you don't even know that a specific disease/injury/condition is possible.) There are of course situations in which an alternative therapy would be helpful but you need to have a diagnosis or a localization of where the pain is stemming from before the you can assume that an alternative type of care may be of benefit.
That would depend very much on the symptoms IME. It may or may not be reasonably obvious that the prob is stemming from joint, muscle, hoof related probs, for eg. The OP has also already consulted her vet & farrier & they are at a loss, so shows that they can't diagnose everything. Perhaps tho she could ask her vet to refer her to a *good* bodyworker.
Many of the conditions that a chiro or body worker may be able to help with also are not the main problem but rather the result of a medical condition elsewhere in the body. For example, lameness in a leg or foot can lead to a difference in the way that the body is used/moved that can lead to intense muscle pain or the back getting out of alignment.
Agree thoroughly with that. While bodywork or veterinary isn't my area of expertise, I can tell you that I've worked with many horses with hoof probs which have gone un- or mis-diagnosed by vets, and that hoof probs generally go hand in hand with body issues. I've also had bodyworkers refer horses to me because they recognise hoof imbalance being a factor or cause, and I would hope that any bodyworker worth his pay would have at least a general knowledge about that sort of thing. In most cases tho, it's difficult or impossible to work out which came first - did neglected or badly managed hooves lead to body issues or did body issues or something else(such as diet) cause hoof imbalance? And just 'fixing' hooves doesn't generally mean body issues will go away of their own accord, or vice versa. Therefore, I'm in no way saying do without the vet, but it *generally* takes a more holistic approach, and vets can *generally* only go so far.